2) Kalisto
Kalisto has won a few Titles in WWE. He has won NXT Tag Team gold. He is also a former WWE United States and WWE Cruiserweight Champion. Here is a photo of Kalisto without his mask:
Holy crap. Kalisto unmasked really does look like a gay hairdresser. pic.twitter.com/ePKhrBuu4J
— Still an Adam Cole Guy BAYBAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (@juicypatlucey) July 26, 2015
1) Rey Mysterio
Rey Mysterio has been around for decades in the world of professional wrestling. Mysterio lost his mask back in 1999 in WCW. Here is a recent photo of Rey without his mask:
An Unmasked Rey Mysterio with Mr. T In New Orleans – http://t.co/nFr2MZqfFQ #wwe #tna pic.twitter.com/1yhLKVtBFd
— Daily Wrestling News (@DailyWWENews) April 5, 2014
On a related note, here are some photos of WWE stars without their beards!