Johnny Gargano Matches With The Highest Meltzer Ratings

Johnny Gargano has already put on some incredible matches in his WWE career. Here is a list of the Johnny Gargano matches that have received the most stars from Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Notes: the ratings are on a 5-star scale and we have only included matches with a 4-star rating and above. 

The Highest Rated Johnny Gargano Matches Ever

The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 4.00 Stars

Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Young Bucks

Event: PWG All-Star Weekend XI (2015) | Rating: 4.00 Stars

  • PWG Tag Team Championship match

Johnny Gargano vs Aleister Black vs Killian Dain vs Lars Sullivan

Event: NXT (December 27th, 2017) | Rating: 4.00 Stars

  • Fatal 4-Way match
  • Winner gets an NXT Championship match.

The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 4.25 Stars

Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Authors of Pain

Event: NXT Takeover: Chicago (2017) | Rating: 4.25 Stars

  • NXT Tag Team Championship match
  • Tag Team Ladder match

Johnny Gargano vs Andrade Almas

Event: NXT Takeover: Brooklyn III (2017) | Rating: 4.25 Stars

Johnny Gargano vs Andrade Almas

Event: NXT (February 21st, 2018) | Rating: 4.25 Stars

  • NXT Championship match
  • If Gargano lost, he would have had to leave NXT.

The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 4.5 Stars

Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Revival

Event: NXT Takeover: Brooklyn (2016)  | Rating: 4.5 Stars

  • NXT Tag Team Championship match

Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Revival

Event: NXT Takeover: Toronto (2016)  | Rating: 4.5 Stars

  • NXT Tag Team Championship match
  • 2 out of 3 falls match.

Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa vs The Revival vs The Authors of Pain

Event: NXT Takeover: Orlando (2017)  | Rating: 4.5 Stars

  • NXT Tag Team Championship match
  • Three-way tag team elimination

Johnny Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa

Event: NXT Takeover: Chicago II (2018)  | Rating: 4.5 Stars

  • Chicago Street Fight

Johnny Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa

Event: NXT Takeover: Brooklyn IV (2018)  | Rating: 4.5 Stars

  • NXT Championship match
  • Last Man Standing

The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 4.75 Stars

Johnny Gargano vs Aleister Black

Event: NXT Takeover: War Games II (2018)  | Rating: 4.75 Stars

Johnny Gargano vs Ricochet

Event: NXT Takeover: Phoenix (2019)  | Rating: 4.75 Stars

  • NXT North American Championship

The Following Johnny Gargano Matches Have Received 5.00 Stars

Johnny Gargano vs Andrade Almas

Event: NXT Takeover: Philadelphia (2018)  | Rating: 5.00 Stars

  • NXT Championship match

Johnny Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa

Event: NXT Takeover: New Orleans (2018)  | Rating: 5.00 Stars

  • Unsanctioned match

Johnny Gargano vs Adam Cole

Event: NXT Takeover: New York (2019)  | Rating: 5.5 Stars

  • 2 out of 3 falls match for the NXT Championship.

READ NEXT: List Of The Highest-Rated AJ Styles Matches In WWE History

What are some of your favorite Johnny Gargano matches? Let us know in the comment section below.