There is no question that Roman Reigns is a major star in WWE. Here are all of his match ratings according to Dave Meltzer. Ratings are from the Wrestling Observer Newsletter (subscribe here). If you are a subscriber, you can read the full justification for his ratings.
List Of All The Roman Reigns – Dave Meltzer Star Ratings
Other Star Ratings: AJ Styles | Sasha Banks | Becky Lynch | Charlotte Flair | Alexa Bliss | Kevin Owens | Sami Zayn
Listed by Event – Match – Star Rating (out of 5).
| Event | Match | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| WWE Survivor Series 2017 | The Shield vs the New Day | 3.75 |
| WWE No Mercy 2017 | Roman Reigns vs John Cena | 4.25 |
| WWE SummerSlam 2017 | Roman Reigns vs Brock Lesnar vs Samoa Joe vs Braun Strowman | 4.75 |
| WWE Great Balls Of Fire 2017 | Roman Reigns vs Braun Strowman | 3.75 |
| WWE Extreme Rules 2017 | Roman Reigns vs Finn Balor vs Bray Wyatt vs Samoa Joe vs Seth Rollins | 4.5 |
| WWE Payback 2017 | Roman Reigns vs Braun Strowman | 3.25 |
| WWE WrestleMania 33 | Roman Reigns vs the Undertaker | 3.00 |
| WWE Fastlane 2017 | Roman Reigns vs Braun Strowman | 4.00 |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2017 | Royal Rumble Match | 3.75 |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2017 | Roman Reigns vs Kevin Owens | 4.5 |
| WWE Roadblock: End Of The Line | Roman Reigns vs Kevin Owens | 3.00 |
| WWE Survivor Series 2016 | Team RAW vs Team Smackdown Live (Men’s Elimination Match) | 4.5 |
| WWE Hell In A Cell 2016 | Roman Reigns vs Rusev | 3.25 |
| WWE Clash Of Champions 2016 | Roman Reigns vs Rusev | 3.5 |
| WWE RAW: July 25th 2016 | Roman Reigns vs Finn Balor | 3.25 |
| WWE RAW: July 25th 2016 | Roman Reigns vs Sheamus vs Chris Jericho vs Sami Zayn | 3.5 |
| WWE Battleground 2016 | Roman Reigns vs Seth Rollins vs Dean Ambrose | 4.00 |
| WWE Money In The Bank 2016 | Roman Reigns vs Seth Rollins | 3.75 |
| WWE Extreme Rules 2016 | Roman Reigns vs AJ Styles | 4.5 |
| WWE Payback 2016 | Roman Reigns vs AJ Styles | 3.75 |
| WWE WrestleMania 32 | Roman Reigns vs Triple H | 3.25 |
| WWE Fastlane 2016 | Roman Reigns vs Dean Ambrose vs Brock Lesnar | 4.5 |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2016 | Royal Rumble Match | 4.00 |
| WWE TLC 2015 | Roman Reigns vs Sheamus | 4.00 |
| WWE Survivor Series 2015 | Roman Reigns vs Dean Ambrose | 3.5 |
| WWE Survivor Series 2015 | Roman Reigns vs Alberto Del Rio | 3.5 |
| WWE RAW: November 16th 2015 | Roman Reigns vs Cesaro | 4.25 |
| WWE Hell In A Cell 2015 | Roman Reigns vs Bray Wyatt | 3.75 |
| WWE Night Of Champions 2015 | Roman Reigns, Dean Ambrose & Chris Jericho vs Braun Strowman, Bray Wyatt & Luke Harper | 4.00 |
| WWE SummerSlam 2015 | Roman Reigns & Dean Ambrose vs Bray Wyatt & Braun Strowman | 3.5 |
| WWE Battleground 2015 | Roman Reigns vs Bray Wyatt | 3.75 |
| WWE Money In The Bank 2015 | Money In The Bank Ladder Match | 3.5 |
| WWE Payback 2015 | Roman Reigns vs Randy Orton vs Dean Ambrose vs Seth Rollins | 3.75 |
| WWE Extreme Rules 2015 | Roman Reigns vs The Big Show | 4.00 |
| WWE WrestleMania 31 | Roman Reigns vs Brock Lesnar (vs Seth Rollins) | 4.5 |
| WWE Fastlane 2015 | Roman Reigns vs Daniel Bryan | 4.5 |
| WWE Royal Rumble 2015 | Royal Rumble Match | 1.75 |
| WWE SummerSlam 2014 | Roman Reigns vs Randy Orton | 4.00 |
| WWE Battleground 2014 | Roman Reigns vs John Cena vs Randy Orton vs Kane | 3.25 |
| WWE Money In The Bank 2014 | Roman Reigns vs John Cena vs Randy Orton vs Kane vs Sheamus vs Cesaro vs Bray Wyatt vs Alberto Del Rio | 4.00 |
| WWE Payback 2014 | The Shield vs Evolution | 4.00 |
| WWE Extreme Rules 2014 | The Shield vs Evolution | 4.5 |
| WWE Main Event (April 8th 2014) | The Shield vs The Wyatt Family | 4.25 |
| WWE WrestleMania 30 | The Shield vs Billy Gunn, Kane & Road Dogg | 2.00 |
| WWE RAW: March 3rd 2014 | The Shield vs The Wyatt Family | 4.5 |
| WWE Elimination Chamber 2014 | The Shield vs The Wyatt Family | 4.25 |
| WWE Smackdown: February 11th 2014 | The Shield vs Daniel Bryan, Sheamus & Christian | 3.75 |
| WWE Royal Rumble ’14 | Royal Rumble Match | 3.25 |
| WWE TLC 2013 | The Shield vs CM Punk | 3.00 |
| WWE Survivor Series 2013 | The Shield & The Real Americans vs The Usos, Cody Rhodes, Goldust & Rey Mysterio | 3.5 |
| WWE RAW: November 18th 2013 | The Shield & The Wyatt Family vs CM Punk, Cody Rhodes, Daniel Bryan, Goldust & The Usos | 3.75 |
| WWE Hell In A Cell 2013 | Roman Reigns & Seth Rollins vs the Usos vs Cody Rhodes & Goldust | 4.00 |
| WWE RAW: October 14th 2013 | Roman Reigns & Seth Rollins vs Cody Rhodes & Goldust | 4.00 |
| WWE Battleground 2013 | Roman Reigns & Seth Rollins vs Cody Rhodes & Goldust | 3.5 |
| WWE Night Of Champions 2013 | Roman Reigns & Seth Rollins vs The Prime Time Players | 2.5 |
| WWE Money In The Bank 2013 | Roman Reigns & Seth Rollins vs the Usos | 3.5 |
| WWE Payback 2013 | Roman Reigns & Seth Rollins vs Daniel Bryan & Randy Orton | 3.5 |
| WWE Extreme Rules 2013 | Roman Reigns & Seth Rollins vs Daniel Bryan & Kane | 2.75 |
| WWE WrestleMania 29 | The Shield vs Randy Orton, the Big Show & Sheamus | 2.5 |
| WWE Elimination Chamber 2013 | The Shield vs Ryback, John Cena & Sheamus | 3.75 |
| WWE TLC 2012 | The Shield vs Ryback, Daniel Bryan & Kane | 4.5 |
Here is a list of all of the 5-star matches in WWE history
Let us know what you think in the comment section below.